Seemor

Ogliastro Pizza BarB+Worth Trying

Name: Ogliastro Pizza Bar
Address: 784 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, Brooklyn, United States
Rating: 4.5

784 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238 · Pizza restaurant, Bar, Pizza Takeout · 4.5/5 Google (423 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Neighborhood pizza-and-cocktails spot with creative pies, cozy indoor-bar and garden seating, solid service, and fair value; a few complaints about portion size and occasional kitchen or pacing misses.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Ogliastro Pizza Bar delivers solid neighborhood dining through strong food quality anchored by creative, well-executed pizzas and attentive service that makes guests feel welcome. However, inconsistent execution—occasional cold or soggy pies and seasoning variation—prevents the grade A territory this kitchen approaches on its best nights. The charming backyard and cozy bar atmosphere enhance the experience without reaching destination-level appeal, making this a reliable local favorite rather than a must-visit establishment.

Restaurant Summary

Ogliastro lands between cozy neighborhood bar and creative pizza joint, with a room that feels warm and welcoming. Reviews describe staff who make it easy to relax and a backyard that turns birthdays into easygoing celebrations. One diner summed it up nicely: "We felt right at home and the pies kept us smiling." The cooking leans Italian at heart with a playful, contemporary streak: carbonara pizza with silky yolk, lamb sausage with yogurt and honey, seafood with chorizo. Most pies hit that crisp-chewy sweet spot, though a few reports of off nights (cold or soggy) and seasoning swings appear. If you like chef-y combinations without fuss, this is your kind of place. Families do well here. Simple choices like Margherita, pepperoni, and white pies, plus gluten-free and cauliflower crusts, make ordering easy for kids and sensitive eaters. Portions skew modest, so plan an extra pie for hungry teens and save room for the lemon-basil panna cotta.

At a Glance

Creative pies with thoughtful ingredients (carbonara, lamb sausage, seafood options)
Cozy bar and lovely backyard garden for groups
Strong gluten-free and customization options
Portions can feel small for the price
Occasional service lapses and inconsistent pizza temperature/seasoning

What Sets It Apart

creative_pizza_combinations
backyard_garden_seating
robust_gluten_free_options

What People Love

Neighborhood staple energy with friendly staff
Inventive pizzas that still feel comforting
Backyard patio that elevates casual dinners
Gluten-free crust that tastes like the real thing

Points of Concern

Portions, especially some salads, can feel small for the price
A few reports of cold or soggy pies; seafood pizza is polarizing
Service can be slow or distracted at peak times
Review patterns show minor templated owner replies; overall authenticity remains strong

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$42-58 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

For conservative palates, choose Margherita or Pepperoni
Gluten-free diners: request GF crust on Margherita or Funghi
Share 2 pizzas for 2 if hungry due to modest portion sizes

Perfect For

Date night with cocktails and a specialty pie
Neighbor hang with friends in the garden
Gluten-free diners seeking quality crusts
Celebrating low-key birthdays outdoors

Location Insights

Area: Lively, residential-meets-cultural corridor near museums and Prospect Park; attracts neighbors, couples, and small groups.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked evenings with steady footfall; typical Brooklyn urban environment.

Nearby: Close to Brooklyn Museum and Prospect Park; bars, cafes, and boutiques line Washington Ave.

Prospect HeightsProspect Heights offers a dynamic dining environment with a mix of trendy restaurants, casual eateries, and classic Brooklyn establishments. The area is known for its cultural diversity, proximity to Prospect Park, and a community-oriented atmosphere that attracts a mix of locals and visitors seeking both upscale and neighborhood dining experiences.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday17:00–22:00 Tuesday17:00–22:00 Wednesday17:00–22:00 Thursday17:00–22:00 Friday17:00–22:30 Saturday13:00–22:30 Sunday13:00–22:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →