Seemor
The Pie Guy PizzaBWorth Trying
83-85 Baxter St, New York, NY 10013
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.8/5 Google (220 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
A small Chinatown slice shop serving flavorful NY-style pies at budget prices; best for quick bites, with minor consistency and space constraints.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
The Pie Guy Pizza delivers solid neighborhood pizza through strong food quality and warm, efficient service, with exceptional value that keeps regulars coming back. Consistency shows occasional variation in crust execution, and severely limited seating constrains the experience, preventing the higher grades reserved for more well-rounded establishments. It's a dependable counter slice shop that excels at what it does—quick, affordable, flavorful pizza—without pretension.
Restaurant Summary
The vibe is small and bustling: order at the counter, watch slices fly in and out of the oven, and snag a stool or ledge if you can. Staff are warm and efficient, and the sauce gets love from regulars. One diner summed it up: "We were out the door with hot, foldable slices in minutes." However, seating is tight and some off-peak slices can be less crisp. The culinary approach leans elevated traditional: classic New York pies with smart crowd-pleasers like spicy rigatoni, buffalo chicken, and hot-honey pepperoni. It fits anyone chasing a flavorful, affordable slice over theatrics—think crisp reheat, balanced sauce, and budget-friendly whole pies. Expect a dependable counter slice shop, not a destination for elaborate tasting menus. For families, this works well as a quick, low-commitment stop. Kids will eat cheese or pepperoni slices, garlic knots, and the white pie. No kids menu, but portioning by-the-slice keeps it easy. Space is limited inside, so plan on a short stop or takeaway if the stools are full.
At a Glance
- Excellent value for quality slices and pies
- Friendly, fast counter service
- Very limited seating and cramped space
- Occasional inconsistencies (soft crust or sell-outs)
- Standout spicy rigatoni and vodka sauce slices
What Sets It Apart
- budget_slices_with_quality
- spicy_rigatoni_slice
- hot_honey_pepperoni_option
What People Love
- Crispy reheat with balanced sauce
- Flavorful margherita and pepperoni
- Creative yet familiar spicy rigatoni slice
- Prices that feel like a deal downtown
Points of Concern
- Space is tight; only a few stools and a standing shelf
- Quality can dip during slow periods (softer crust reported)
- Popular items sell out; selection may be limited late
- Delivery hiccups reported by a minority of reviewers
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$12-$18 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For kids: classic cheese or white slice plus garlic knots
- Value play: share a $24-$26 whole pie if 2-3 people
- Spice fans: The New Yorker or spicy rigatoni slice
Perfect For
- A fast, tasty slice between downtown errands
- Budget-friendly casual lunch
- Late afternoon snack before a show or game
- Out-of-towners seeking a classic NY slice vibe
Location Insights
Area: Busy downtown corridor between Chinatown and Little Italy; heavy foot traffic with locals and visitors.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked day and evening; standard big-city street awareness advised.
Nearby: Near courts, Columbus Park, and Nolita shops; strong grab-and-go demand and commuter flow.
NolitaNolita is a fashionable and intimate neighborhood known for its boutique shops, art galleries, and a strong culinary scene featuring upscale casual dining and innovative eateries. The area has a lively yet relaxed atmosphere, popular among those seeking a stylish but approachable dining experience.
Little ItalyLittle Italy is a historic enclave within Nolita famous for its Italian-American culture and traditional restaurants. It offers a charming, old-world dining ambiance with many family-run establishments and seasonal street festivals.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–20:00
Tuesday10:00–20:00
Wednesday10:00–20:00
Thursday10:00–00:00
Friday11:00–00:00
Saturday11:00–00:00
Sunday12:00–20:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →