Lively Jamaican spot near Barclays with flavorful meats and big portions, but long reservation waits and uneven service; solid value for hearty entrees, mixed experience for reliability.
The Simpson delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong food quality anchored by tender oxtail and well-seasoned seafood, plus reliable menu knowledge from named servers. However, inconsistent execution on jerk dishes and occasional cold plates prevents grade A territory, while persistent peak-time waits and crowding limit the experience despite convenient location near Barclays. Worth visiting for celebrations and bold Jamaican flavors, but operational inconsistencies keep it from competing with the area's premier dining destinations.
One caveat: Reservation system and seating delays commonly exceed 45-90 minutes at peak