Seemor

The Pie Pizzeria - UndergroundB-Worth Trying

Name: The Pie Pizzeria - Underground
Address: 1320 E 200 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84102, Salt Lake City, United States
Rating: 4.6

1320 E 200 S, Salt Lake City, UT 84102 · Pizza restaurant, Gluten-free restaurant, Italian restaurant · 4.6/5 Google (4174 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout

Lively basement pizzeria near campus serving creative, heavy-on-cheese pies with long bake times and occasional service bottlenecks; great flavors, big portions, tricky parking.

Why it gets a B- for overall quality

The Pie Pizzeria delivers strong food quality with creative, indulgent pies and an iconic underground aesthetic that draws loyal repeat customers and campus visitors. However, quality variation during peak times, inconsistent allergen clarity, and extended wait times prevent higher performance. It's a beloved local institution worth experiencing, but operational inconsistencies keep it from grade A-grade territory.

Restaurant Summary

Down a set of stairs near campus, this spot feels lively and underground in the best way—graffiti-clad walls, a thrum of students, and huge pies sailing from the pickup window. One diner summed it up: "Cheesy, shareable, and worth the wait", though peak times can mean a long bake and a scramble for seats. The cooking leans creative and indulgent—think Thai peanut sauce pies, a cheeseburger pizza with pickles, and beer-reduction specials alongside hefty combos. Expect thick, bready crusts, serious cheese pull, and flavors that favor richness over restraint; most love it, while a minority find certain pies too greasy or doughy when busy. Families do fine here thanks to familiar options like cheese, pepperoni, and pull-aparts, and kids have been known to love the mild buffalo pie. Note there is a 12 inch cauliflower crust add-on and vegetarian choices, but allergy handling has inconsistent clarity; bring specifics and confirm at ordering time.

At a Glance

Big, indulgent pies with creative toppings
Fun underground vibe near campus
Long waits and seating crunch at peak times
Parking is paid and limited
Allergy communication has been inconsistent

What Sets It Apart

underground_graffiti_atmosphere
giant_23_inch_pies
creative_fusion_pizzas

What People Love

The over-the-top cheese and toppings
The unique basement graffiti atmosphere
Huge sizes that feed groups easily
Friendly help at the counter when ordering

Points of Concern

Bake times stretch to 45–120 minutes during events; consider off-peak visits
Some pies arrive greasy or underbaked when slammed
Allergen guidance has been unclear; double-check ingredients
Parking is paid and frustrating near campus

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$20-30 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Choose build-your-own on a large base and add 2–3 toppings for value; consider cauliflower crust only on 12 inch; plan shared starters like Pull-A-Part.

Perfect For

Pre-game carb load before stadium events
Late-night college hang with friends
Sharing a giant pie with a crowd
Casual family dinner with hungry kids

Location Insights

Area: Student-heavy zone by University of Utah; casual, late-night energy, group-friendly.

Safety: Generally safe, busy with students; basement entry is dim but active.

Nearby: Near campus buildings, stadium events, and student housing; paid street and small lot parking.

Central CityCentral City is a vibrant urban neighborhood with a mix of office buildings, apartments, and local businesses. The dining scene includes casual eateries, trendy cafes, and some upscale options, catering mostly to working professionals and residents seeking convenient and diverse food choices.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:00–23:00 Tuesday11:00–23:00 Wednesday11:00–23:00 Thursday11:00–23:00 Friday11:00–23:00 Saturday11:00–23:00 Sunday12:00–22:00

Available: Delivery, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →