Bustling Castro spot for hearty brunch and Mediterranean-leaning comfort dishes with cocktails; strong highs but inconsistent execution and service.
Cafe Mystique delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong food quality anchored by standout pastas and risotti, generous portions, and appealing Castro location with sidewalk seating. However, inconsistent execution—particularly in service speed and occasional allergy mishandling—prevents it from reaching higher territory. It's a reliable local favorite worth visiting, especially for brunch or theater nights, but lacks the consistency and distinction of the area's premier restaurants.
One caveat: Service can be slow at brunch with 30-45 minute waits reported