Seemor

North of Brooklyn PizzeriaB+Worth Trying

Name: North of Brooklyn Pizzeria
Address: 229 Geary Ave, Toronto, ON M6H 2C1, Canada, Toronto, Canada
Rating: 4.5

229 Geary Ave, Toronto, ON M6H 2C1, Canada · Pizza restaurant, Pizza delivery, Pizza Takeout · 4.5/5 Google (1396 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Excellent thin-crust slices and pies with standout specialty toppings, best enjoyed on-premise; value is fair-to-good, but delivery consistency and occasional service friction can disappoint.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

North of Brooklyn delivers excellent thin-crust pizza with creative specialties that justify its local reputation, but inconsistent execution between dine-in and delivery prevents a higher grade. The lively bar setting with arcade appeal creates a fun atmosphere for pizza enthusiasts, though service reliability wavers during rushes. Best experienced fresh at the counter rather than via delivery.

Restaurant Summary

Housed within a lively bar setting, North of Brooklyn feels warm and bustling rather than fussy. The action centers on crisp, foldable slices and chatty counter exchanges, and one diner raved, "Eat it at the bar for the best experience." Expect the industrial-arcade vibe to hum on weekends, with staff who can be wonderfully helpful when things are flowing. The cooking leans classic New York with modern flourishes: a thin, airy crust that crackles, hot-honey heat on Killer Bee, earthy truffle notes for mushroom lovers, and a vivid Vodka Verde swirl. It is comfort-forward, ingredient-driven, and best when fresh from the oven rather than delivered across town. For families, slices and simple pies work well earlier in the evening, but note the bar environment and reports of a 19-plus policy after 8pm. Kids who like plain cheese or pepperoni will be fine, while adventurous eaters may go for Truffle Shuffle; if you need a kids menu or quieter room, try daytime hours.

At a Glance

Excellent thin-crust NY-style pies, best enjoyed fresh on-site
Creative but accessible specialties like Killer Bee and Truffle Shuffle
Delivery can arrive cold or late; dine-in is more consistent
Bar environment with potential age limits after 8pm
Inconsistent slice reheats and occasional burnt pies during rush

What Sets It Apart

bar_collaboration_space
specialty_hot_honey_pie
truffle_forward_vegetarian_option
slice_counter_plus_full_pies

What People Love

Thin, crisp yet airy crust with a great fold
Hot-honey and truffle flavor pops
Easygoing bar setup with patios and games
Reliable go-to for locals and repeat orders

Points of Concern

Delivery reliability issues: multiple reports of cold or delayed pies
Occasional rude or disorganized service at peak times
Bar-linked policies (age limits after 8pm) can surprise families
Hygiene lapses reported at slice counter on isolated occasions

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average CostC$24-38 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Order a medium pie (C$20-22) plus knots (C$4-7) to share; vegetarians have multiple pie choices and vegan cheese substitution.

Perfect For

Casual pizza night with drinks
Post-show or game hang with slices
Vegetarian-friendly pizza cravings
Quick solo bite at the bar

Location Insights

Area: Industrial-chic corridor with bars, venues, and creative studios; draws locals and night crowds more than tourists.

Safety: Generally safe with active nightlife foot traffic; occasional late-night crowding typical for bar-linked venues.

Nearby: Located within/adjacent to The Greater Good bar; arcade games, patios, nearby music venues and breweries.

Dovercourt-Wallace Emerson-JunctionThe dining scene here is eclectic and vibrant, featuring a blend of traditional ethnic eateries, trendy cafes, and new restaurants reflecting the area's cultural diversity. The neighborhood has a friendly, community-oriented atmosphere with a growing appeal to food enthusiasts seeking authentic and affordable dining options.

Dovercourt VillageDovercourt Village is known for its hip, laid-back vibe with an increasing number of boutique restaurants, craft breweries, and coffee shops. It balances a residential feel with a lively dining and social scene, making it popular for casual dining and weekend outings.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday17:00–00:00 Tuesday17:00–00:00 Wednesday17:00–00:00 Thursday17:00–00:00 Friday15:00–02:00 Saturday15:00–02:00 Sunday15:00–00:00

Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →