Seemor

Key West › Key West › Old Town

Best Restaurants in Old Town

17 restaurants analyzed · Key West

Old Town is where Key West's seafood and American cooking shine brightest, with open-air restaurants along Duval Street and the harbor serving the kind of fresh catch and Caribbean-inflected dishes that justify the higher prices. The neighbourhood rewards a leisurely dinner rather than a quick bite, making it a natural fit for a special occasion or a long evening with no particular agenda. If you're after grilled fish that actually came off a local boat that morning, this is the right part of the island to start looking.

Restaurants

• Cafe Marquesa A · Fine dining restaurant, New American
• Red Shoe Island Bistro A · Bistro, Seafood
• 7 Fish A- · Seafood restaurant, Contemporary American
• El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown) A- · Cuban restaurant, Caribbean
• Little Pearl B+ · Chef-driven tasting menu, Seafood-forward
• Lola's Bistro Key West B+ · Chef-driven bistro, BYOB
• DJ's Clam Shack B+ · Seafood, Casual
• The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. B+ · Restaurant, Seafood
• Thirsty Mermaid B+ · Seafood restaurant, Raw bar
• Kaya Island Eats B+ · Casual restaurant, Bar

Top Cuisines

• American — 6 restaurants
• Caribbean — 2 restaurants
• New American — 2 restaurants
• Modern American — 1 restaurants
• Contemporary American — 1 restaurants
• European — 1 restaurants
• Seafood — 1 restaurants
• Mediterranean — 1 restaurants
• Bakery — 1 restaurants
• Desserts — 1 restaurants

Find Your Next Meal in Old Town

• Casual Meal restaurants in Old Town — Quick, quality, no fuss
• Date Night restaurants in Old Town — Romantic dining for two
• Fun with Friends restaurants in Old Town — Something everyone will enjoy
• Family Outing restaurants in Old Town — Kid-friendly, stress-free dining
• Solo Dining restaurants in Old Town — Comfortable spots for dining alone
• Business Discussion restaurants in Old Town — Professional setting, no distractions
• Vegetarian-Friendly restaurants in Old Town
• Vegan-Friendly restaurants in Old Town
• Gluten-Free Friendly restaurants in Old Town
• Walk-ins Welcome restaurants in Old Town
• Private Dining restaurants in Old Town
• Local Favorites restaurants in Old Town
• Easy Parking restaurants in Old Town
• Amazing Setting restaurants in Old Town
• Hidden Gems restaurants in Old Town
• Great Value restaurants in Old Town

Explore Old Town on Seemor →