High-energy Polanco spot for creative tacos, USDA steaks, and cocktails; delicious but loud, pricey, and reports of smoking and billing surprises make it a better pick for a lively night out than a quiet dinner.
Colmillo Masaryk delivers excellent food quality anchored by standout steaks, fresh seafood, and tableside guacamole, paired with a stylish Masaryk setting that draws diners seeking a destination experience. Inconsistent execution on dishes and service attentiveness prevents a higher grade, with some guests encountering over-salted plates or delayed courses alongside many seamless visits. Strong cocktails and loyal following underscore its appeal, though reliability gaps keep it from approaching the very top tier.
On Masaryk, Colmillo pulses with high-energy glamour: dark, stylish interiors, thumping playlists, and servers whisking out flaming mezcal steaks. Guests rave about tender octopus, creative tacos, and tableside guac. However, there are some review authenticity concerns and recurring notes about indoor smoking. One diner summed it up: "Great food and vibe, but louder than expected and pricey." The kitchen leans modern and cross-cultural rather than strictly traditional, with USDA cuts, Japanese-tinged tacos, and truffle-forward sides. Expect creative twists on Mexican staples, shareable portions, and theatrical touches. It suits celebratory nights, cocktails, and steak lovers who enjoy a scene more than hushed conversation. Families do fine here thanks to a dedicated kids meal, burgers, pastas, and familiar sides. That said, the volume, occasional smoking reports, and premium pricing mean it is better for flexible eaters than picky ones. Ask for a quieter table if bringing children.
Area vibe: Upscale shopping and dining corridor in Polanco, popular with business diners and weekend revelers.
Safety: Well-patrolled, busy streets and valet presence; generally safe with high foot traffic at night.
What's nearby: Along Avenida Masaryk near luxury boutiques, hotels, and bars; lively nightlife and business crowd.