Boundary-pushing Modern Mexican tasting menu with stellar highs; service is usually polished but inconsistent for some, pricing is ultra-premium, and there are credible clusters of foodborne illness complaints to weigh carefully.
Quintonil delivers exceptional creative Modern Mexican cuisine with knowledgeable service and thoughtful pairings, positioning it as a competitive neighborhood fine-dining destination. However, documented food safety concerns and inconsistent execution across visits prevent a higher grade—diners should expect memorable courses alongside occasional disappointments and operational variability. The polished Polanco setting and theatrical chef counter appeal to adventurous tasting-menu enthusiasts willing to accept some risk for culinary innovation.
One caveat: Pricing is genuinely expensive (MX$6,000+ menus; premium drinks escalate checks)