Seemor

Gebhard's Beer CultureB-

228 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023 · Restaurant, Bar · Upper West Side

Lively craft beer bar with pinball upstairs and a solid bar-food menu; great beers and wings, order-at-the-bar service, but avoid Thursday podcast hours if you prefer calm.

Why this grade

Gebhard's delivers reliable neighborhood appeal with strong food quality highlighted by excellent wings and smash burgers, though consistency shows occasional quality variation on items like chicken and fries during busy shifts. Friendly bartenders and a convenient location near Beacon with upstairs pinball add character, but the order-at-bar model and service speed challenges during peak times keep it from reaching higher territory. Worth visiting for craft beer selection and casual comfort food, though Thursday podcast events shift the vibe significantly.

One caveat: Thursday podcast hours can be loud and divisive for diners

What to order here

What stands out

Opening Hours

Monday15:00–00:00 Tuesday15:00–00:00 Wednesday15:00–00:00 Thursday15:00–02:00 Friday12:00–02:00 Saturday12:00–02:00 Sunday12:00–00:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →