Seemor

Pop's PizzaA-Worth Trying

Name: Pop's Pizza
Address: 301 W 57th St Ground floor, New York, NY 10019, New York, United States
Rating: 4.8

301 W 57th St Ground floor, New York, NY 10019 · Pizza restaurant, Fast food restaurant, Pizza delivery · 4.8/5 Google (1349 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

High-praise Midtown slice shop near Central Park serving large, thin-crust pies and slices; excellent flavors and speed with cramped standing-only space and occasional service brusqueness.

Why it gets an A- for overall quality

Pop's Pizza delivers exceptional food quality with crisp, foldable slices and outstanding speed that justify its stellar reputation among Midtown regulars and park-goers. Consistency shows occasional variation in execution, and the cramped standing-only setup limits comfort, preventing the higher distinction needed for grade A territory. Strong value and convenient location make it a reliable neighborhood favorite rather than a destination standout.

Restaurant Summary

A Midtown West slice window that feels warm and bustling, Pop’s draws steady lines of park-bound snackers and office regulars. Reviewers rave about crisp, foldable slices and speed: one put it simply, "we had slices in under five minutes." Space is tight with standing-only counters outside, so expect grab-and-go energy. The cooking leans classic New York more than experimental, with a few fun twists like pepperoni with jalapeño and chili honey. The culinary approach is comfort-first and sauce-forward: big, thin slices, clean flavors, and toppings that please a crowd. Fans swear by the Margherita, vodka, and spinach-mushroom; a minority call some slices oily or bland, so picking fresher pies in the case helps. For families, it is kid-friendly on the food—cheese and pepperoni are slam dunks, and huge slices split easily. The catch is standing-only space and a tiny interior, which can challenge strollers. Many head to Central Park to eat, an easy win for kids who want room to roam.

At a Glance

Big, tasty slices near Central Park with fast service
Excellent value for Midtown; bundles and fair slice prices
Cramped, standing-only setup; not stroller-friendly
Occasional brusque service or labeling mix-ups
Popular items can sell out during busy times

What Sets It Apart

park_proximity_for_picnics
very_large_slices
fast-moving_lines

What People Love

Large, crisp slices that fold just right
Margherita and vodka slices that taste fresh and saucy
Lines that move quickly even when crowded
Easy walk from Columbus Circle and the park

Points of Concern

Standing-only and very small interior; limited comfort during peak hours
Service can feel rushed or curt when busy
Quality varies by slice freshness; a few report oily or bland bites
Popular styles sell out, limiting choices late day

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$12-$18 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Choose a full pie for groups to lock in freshness and value
Vegetarian and vegan pies are available; confirm slice availability earlier in the day

Perfect For

Grabbing a quick slice before a Central Park stroll
Affordable lunch on a busy Midtown day
Late-day snack when you want something fast
Picnic with a full pie split among friends

Location Insights

Area: Busy Midtown West near Columbus Circle and Central Park; heavy foot traffic with office workers and tourists.

Safety: Well-lit, high-traffic Midtown corridor; generally safe with typical urban congestion.

Nearby: Steps from Columbus Circle transit, Central Park, retail corridors, hotels, and offices.

Hell's KitchenHell's Kitchen offers a vibrant dining scene with a mix of casual eateries, trendy restaurants, and diverse international cuisines. The area is lively, with a strong nightlife presence and proximity to Broadway theaters, attracting both locals and tourists seeking varied dining experiences.

nullnull

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday10:00–23:00 Tuesday10:00–23:00 Wednesday10:00–23:00 Thursday10:00–23:00 Friday10:00–23:00 Saturday10:00–23:00 Sunday10:00–23:00

Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →