Excellent baked Argentinian empanadas in the Turnstyle subway market; fast, friendly, and flavorful, with some complaints about price, occasional sogginess, and a few isolated food safety reports.
Criollas @ Columbus Circle Underground Market delivers excellent food quality with flaky, well-stuffed empanadas and attentive, friendly service that makes it a solid neighborhood choice. However, occasional consistency issues—soggy or lukewarm items during busy periods—and isolated food safety reports prevent a higher grade. The convenient Turnstyle location and fast counter service suit grab-and-go diners well, though the market setting lacks the ambiance or destination appeal of full-service restaurants.
One caveat: Pricing can add up, especially with sauces or drinks