Seemor

My Pie Pizzeria RomanaB+

690 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States · Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Vegan restaurant

Crispy, airy Roman-style square slices with lots of vegetarian options and a few vegan no-cheese pies; quick counter service, tiny dine-in, solid value for Midtown.

Why this grade

My Pie Pizzeria Romana delivers solid neighborhood quality through excellent Roman-style crust and generous toppings paired with quick, friendly service. Very limited seating constrains the experience for groups, and modest ambiance keeps it a casual grab-and-go destination rather than a destination dining spot. Reliable execution and fair value make it worth visiting for quality pizza slices in Midtown.

One caveat: Slices occasionally underheated or a bit floppy at busy times (minor but noted)

What to order here

What stands out

Opening Hours

Monday10:30–20:30 Tuesday10:30–20:30 Wednesday10:30–20:30 Thursday10:30–20:30 Friday10:30–20:30 Saturday10:30–20:30 Sunday10:30–20:30
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →