Seemor
My Pie Pizzeria RomanaB+Worth Trying
690 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Vegan restaurant
· 4.7/5 Google (1679 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Crispy, airy Roman-style square slices with lots of vegetarian options and a few vegan no-cheese pies; quick counter service, tiny dine-in, solid value for Midtown.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
My Pie Pizzeria Romana delivers solid neighborhood quality through excellent Roman-style crust and generous toppings paired with quick, friendly service. Very limited seating constrains the experience for groups, and modest ambiance keeps it a casual grab-and-go destination rather than a destination dining spot. Reliable execution and fair value make it worth visiting for quality pizza slices in Midtown.
Restaurant Summary
A compact Midtown East slice shop turning out Roman-style squares with a crisp, airy crust and generous toppings. Diners highlight quick, friendly service and cleanliness, calling out the Nonnina and truffle mushroom as standouts. One visitor put it simply: the slices hit fast and satisfy without weighing you down. The culinary approach leans classic Italian with a Roman al taglio format—elevated traditional rather than experimental. Expect familiar combos like Margherita, pepperoni, and potato rosemary alongside richer picks like buffalo chicken and truffle mushroom. It suits office lunches and casual bites where quality ingredients and speed matter more than ceremony. Families should find it accessible: kids can stick to plain cheese or Margherita, while adventurous teens may like buffalo chicken. Seating is very limited, so plan to grab-and-go if traveling as a group. Vegans have no-cheese options with seasonal veggies; there is no vegan cheese on the current menu.
At a Glance
- Crispy, airy Roman-style crust with generous toppings
- Fast counter service and friendly staff
- Many vegetarian pies plus vegan no-cheese options
- Very limited seating; groups should plan for takeaway
- Vegan options lack plant-based cheese, which some dislike
What Sets It Apart
- Roman-style square slices
- Large, filling portions
- Strong vegetarian selection
What People Love
- Light yet filling crust texture
- Garlic-forward Nonnina slice
- Truffle mushroom richness
- Consistently quick service
Points of Concern
- Slices occasionally underheated or a bit floppy at busy times (minor but noted)
- Vegan options are no-cheese only; some vegans consider this inadequate
- Tiny dining area; seating often limited to pairs
- Pricing above basic slice shops due to style and ingredients, though fair for Midtown
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$18-$24 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For vegetarians: Truffle Oil & Mushroom or Potato Rosemary for a hearty bite
- For vegans: Vegan Seasonal Veggies (no cheese) with added oregano and garlic drizzle
- For kids: Mozzarella Cheese or Margherita warmed extra-hot for melty appeal
Perfect For
- Quick Midtown lunch between meetings
- Casual solo bite after shopping
- Vegetarian-friendly pizza craving
- Grab-and-go dinner on the way home
Location Insights
Area: Busy Midtown East corridor serving office workers, shoppers, and tourists seeking quick bites.
Safety: High foot traffic, well-lit commercial blocks, generally safe day and evening.
Nearby: Near offices and retail like Bloomingdale’s; convenient to hotels and Lexington Ave transit.
Turtle BayTurtle Bay is a well-established residential and commercial neighborhood with a mix of upscale dining, casual eateries, and international cuisine. The area is frequented by office workers during weekdays and residents in the evenings, offering a sophisticated yet approachable dining atmosphere.
East 50sThe East 50s micro-neighborhood is characterized by luxury high-rises, boutique hotels, and fine dining establishments, attracting a clientele that appreciates refined and diverse culinary experiences in a safe and accessible environment.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:30–20:30
Tuesday10:30–20:30
Wednesday10:30–20:30
Thursday10:30–20:30
Friday10:30–20:30
Saturday10:30–20:30
Sunday10:30–20:30
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →