Seemor

Tiny's & The Bar UpstairsB+Worth Trying

Name: Tiny's & The Bar Upstairs
Address: 135 W Broadway, New York, NY 10013, New York, United States
Rating: 4.4

135 W Broadway, New York, NY 10013 · American restaurant, Bar, Breakfast restaurant · 4.4/5 Google (972 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Charming historic townhouse for cocktails and modern American fare; great vibes and some standout dishes, but service can be uneven and pricing adds up.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Tiny's & The Bar Upstairs delivers solid neighborhood dining anchored by exceptional setting appeal—the historic 1810 townhouse with its distinctive pink facade and intimate rooms creates genuine charm that justifies its destination appeal. Food quality shines with standout dishes like the house burger, tater tots, and Kit Kat cake, while the cocktail program earns consistent praise. However, inconsistent execution and occasional service delays at peak hours prevent a higher grade, making this a reliable but not exceptional choice for brunch or cocktails.

Restaurant Summary

The pink 1810 townhouse sets the scene: warm and moody rooms, flickering candles, and an upstairs bar where bartenders craft confident classics. Guests praise the vibe and call out details like matchbooks and brick walls, with one noting, "The setting is the star—charming and photogenic." Peak times can feel lively and loud, and waits for tables or checks occasionally creep in. The cooking leans modern American with elevated comfort: a much-loved house burger, house-made tater tots with special sauce, fresh raw bar, and a pumpkin risotto that wins fans. Not every dish hits—there are scattered notes of under-seasoning or a cold plate—but most diners find quality solid, especially paired with the well-made cocktails and a dessert finale like the Kit Kat. Families will find brunch approachable: pancakes (gluten-free buckwheat), waffles, burgers, fries, and steak and eggs are kid-friendly options. Evenings skew adult with dim lighting and a bustling upstairs bar, so earlier reservations work better for kids. No formal kids menu noted, but the menu has enough familiar picks to keep younger diners happy.

At a Glance

Unique historic townhouse setting with intimate, cozy rooms
Strong cocktail program and popular upstairs bar
Standout bites—house burger, tater tots, oysters, and Kit Kat dessert
Service can be slow or rushed at peak hours
Pricing adds up quickly, especially cocktails and brunch

What Sets It Apart

historic_townhouse_charm
upstairs_cocktail_bar
happy_hour_oysters
private_event_room

What People Love

Charming, distinctive space that feels classic NYC
Bartenders who execute off-menu cocktails well
Tater tots and raw bar as craveable starters
Desserts that end the meal on a high note

Points of Concern

Peak-time delays for drinks and check; occasional rushing
Inconsistent dishes reported (cold plates or light seasoning) amid many positives
Dim lighting and tight waiting areas can be uncomfortable when crowded
Holiday or event fixed-price menus may limit choice and surprise on cost

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$55-75 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Vegetarian diners: Ricotta Cavatelli or Pumpkin Risotto for dinner; GF pancakes or Veggie Grain Bowl for brunch.
Seafood fans: Start with oysters, ceviche, or salmon tartare; follow with branzino or paella.
Value play: Share tater tots and an appetizer, split a dessert, and lean on wine by the glass.

Perfect For

Date night with cocktails and shared plates
Small-group brunch after a neighborhood walk
After-work oysters and drinks
Intimate private events upstairs

Location Insights

Area: Upscale TriBeCa townhouse block attracting locals, date nights, and after-work drinks; intimate, design-forward vibe.

Safety: Well-lit, high-foot-traffic and generally very safe area, even late.

Nearby: Near Hudson River Park, offices, boutiques, and other TriBeCa restaurants and bars.

TribecaTribeca is an upscale neighborhood known for its cobblestone streets, converted industrial buildings, and a thriving dining scene featuring high-end restaurants and trendy cafes. The area attracts a sophisticated crowd seeking quality dining experiences in a stylish, yet relaxed atmosphere.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:00–22:00 Tuesday11:00–22:30 Wednesday11:00–22:30 Thursday11:00–23:00 Friday11:00–23:00 Saturday10:00–23:00 Sunday10:00–22:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →